Foot and ankle injuries are among the most common musculoskeletal issues treated in orthopaedics. At Premier Orthopaedics & Sports Medicine, P.C., serving Bloomfield, NJ; Englewood, NJ; Kearny, NJ; and Union City, NJ, education is a key component in helping patients understand the path to recovery. One of the most frequently asked questions by patients with foot or ankle fractures is whether surgery is necessary for healing. While many fractures heal with non-surgical treatments such as casting or bracing, certain situations require surgical intervention to restore proper function and alignment. This blog explores when surgery becomes necessary, the different types of fractures, and what to expect from the healing process.
Understanding Foot and Ankle Fractures
The human foot and ankle are made up of 26 bones, 33 joints, and over 100 muscles, tendons, and ligaments. This intricate structure allows for stability, movement, and weight-bearing—but also makes the area vulnerable to injury. A fracture in the foot or ankle can occur due to trauma such as a fall, sports injury, or car accident. It may also result from overuse or stress over time, particularly in athletes or individuals with compromised bone density.
Foot and ankle fractures can range in severity from hairline cracks to complex breaks involving multiple bones and joints. While some injuries may present with immediate swelling and an inability to bear weight, others might cause only mild discomfort initially. Accurate diagnosis often requires imaging like X-rays, CT scans, or MRIs to assess the extent and location of the fracture. Early and precise evaluation is essential, as untreated or poorly managed fractures can lead to long-term complications such as arthritis, deformity, or chronic pain.
When Non-Surgical Treatment Is Sufficient
Many foot and ankle fractures can heal without surgical intervention, especially if the bones remain aligned and stable. In these cases, conservative treatments such as immobilization in a cast, boot, or splint are effective. Rest, ice, compression, and elevation (RICE) are commonly recommended during the initial recovery period to reduce swelling and pain. Weight-bearing is typically restricted, and crutches or a walker may be necessary to avoid placing stress on the injury.
Orthopaedic physicians monitor healing through regular follow-up visits and imaging to ensure the bones are healing in proper alignment. If healing proceeds as expected and the patient follows medical advice closely, many can return to full function within several weeks to months. However, conservative treatment is only effective if the fracture is simple and the joint remains stable. When the injury is more complex, surgery may be necessary to avoid long-term dysfunction.
Signs a Fracture May Require Surgery
Certain signs and characteristics indicate that a fracture may not heal correctly without surgical intervention. Recognizing these red flags is critical for timely treatment and improved outcomes.
- Bone misalignment (displacement): If X-rays show that the broken bone ends are significantly out of place, surgery may be required to realign them.
- Joint involvement: Fractures that extend into a joint often necessitate surgical repair to restore function and prevent arthritis.
- Multiple fractures: Complex injuries involving more than one bone or multiple fracture lines may not remain stable without internal fixation.
- Open fractures: When bone punctures the skin, the risk of infection increases, and surgical cleaning and stabilization are often needed.
- Failure to improve with conservative treatment: If a fracture isn’t healing properly with non-surgical methods, surgical intervention might become necessary.
These factors are evaluated through a combination of physical examination, imaging studies, and the patient’s functional status. Timely surgical decision-making can significantly improve healing outcomes and reduce the risk of long-term complications.
Common Surgical Procedures for Foot and Ankle Fractures
When surgery is required, the goal is to restore proper alignment and stability to the fractured area to promote natural healing. The type of surgery performed depends on the location and severity of the fracture.
One of the most common surgical techniques is open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). In this procedure, the surgeon makes an incision to access the fracture, aligns the bones into their proper position, and secures them with metal plates, screws, or rods. These devices may remain in the body permanently or be removed later if necessary.
For ankle fractures involving ligament damage, reconstruction may be performed in conjunction with bone repair. In some cases, especially with midfoot or forefoot injuries, external fixation devices may be used to stabilize the foot while it heals. Surgery is typically performed under general or regional anesthesia and may be done on an outpatient basis, depending on the complexity of the case.
Recovery from surgery usually involves a period of non-weight-bearing, followed by physical therapy to restore strength, mobility, and balance. While surgery carries risks like infection or blood clots, these complications are rare with proper post-operative care and follow-up.
Healing and Rehabilitation After Surgery
Healing from foot or ankle fracture surgery is a gradual process that typically takes several weeks to months. The initial stage involves inflammation control, immobilization, and pain management. During this time, the patient may need to keep the affected limb elevated and avoid putting any weight on it. Your physician may prescribe medications to manage discomfort and prevent blood clots.
Once the bone begins to heal, the next phase involves gradually reintroducing motion and strength to the foot or ankle. Physical therapy is a vital part of rehabilitation. It may include range-of-motion exercises, strength training, balance work, and gait training to ensure a safe return to regular activity. Recovery timelines vary depending on the patient’s age, overall health, the severity of the fracture, and the type of surgery performed. Athletes or individuals with physically demanding jobs may require more extensive rehabilitation before returning to full activity.
Patience and adherence to medical advice during the healing process are essential. Attempting to walk or bear weight too soon can lead to setbacks or re-injury. Long-term follow-up with your orthopaedic provider ensures the bone is healing as expected and helps identify any complications early.
Preventing Future Injuries
While not all fractures are preventable, certain strategies can reduce the risk of future foot and ankle injuries. Wearing appropriate footwear that supports the foot and provides adequate cushioning is critical, especially during sports or physical labor. Individuals with a history of foot or ankle injuries should be particularly cautious and consider orthotics or ankle braces when engaging in high-impact activities.
Maintaining good bone health is another essential factor. Adequate calcium and vitamin D intake, along with regular weight-bearing exercise, helps strengthen bones and prevent fractures. People with osteoporosis or other conditions affecting bone density should work closely with their healthcare providers to monitor and manage their bone health proactively.
Finally, practicing proper technique during physical activities, warming up before exercise, and improving overall balance and flexibility can all contribute to injury prevention. While accidents can happen, many foot and ankle fractures are the result of avoidable missteps or overuse that can be mitigated with awareness and preparation.
Conclusion
Foot and ankle fractures are complex injuries that require accurate diagnosis and thoughtful management. While many fractures can heal with conservative treatments, surgery is sometimes necessary to ensure proper alignment and function. Understanding the indicators that suggest surgical intervention is crucial for patients aiming for a full and pain-free recovery. At Premier Orthopaedics & Sports Medicine, P.C., located in Bloomfield, Englewood, Kearny, and Union City, NJ, patients are encouraged to seek timely evaluation and make informed decisions about their care. With the right approach, even serious fractures can heal well and allow for a return to normal activities.
Sources:
Rammelt, S., & Zwipp, H. (2004). Fractures of the foot and ankle. Injury, 35(2), 91–99.
Court-Brown, C. M., & Caesar, B. (2006). Epidemiology of adult fractures: A review. Injury, 37(8), 691–697.
Schepers, T. (2011). To retain or remove the syndesmotic screw: a review of literature. Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, 131(7), 879–883.
